Series 8 Thoughts
July 13 2025
I know I said I would do a Day of the Doctor and Time of the Doctor but I don't have a lot to say about them. They're just really good (TDotD 10/10, TTotD 9/10). Anyway, here are my thoughts on Capaldi's first season on the show, Series 8!
Overall series rating: 8/10
Here are my ratings for each episode of the season:
- Deep Breath: 9/10
- Into the Dalek: 7/10
- Robot of Sherwood: 7/10
- Listen: 10/10
- Time Heist: 9/10
- The Caretaker: 8/10
- Kill the Moon: 4/10
- Mummy on the Orient Express: 10/10
- Flatline: 10/10
- In the Forest of the Night: 5/10
- Dark Water: 8/10
- Death in Heaven: 9/10
After Series 7, Moffat really needed a comeback. This is exactly that. The overarching plot of this Series isn't something as grand or big as the previous Moffat seasons, it keeps things really simple. In the 3 series' of the epic 11th Doctor and his legendary exploits, we see armies and villains shiver at the mere mention of his name. This series has us question if he is truly is a good man? Capaldi's Doctor starts off pretty rough and at times unlikeable, but as the Series goes on we see that he isn't so bad. Regeneration is a lottery and this series definitely plays with that concept, with Clara almost leaving the Doctor (and also literally threatening him).
The series starts really well with Deep Breath, a great opener and an introduction to 12. It shows that this Doctor is very different to 11, and sometimes is a bit tough to like. But he is still the Doctor that we all love to see. The hints about Missy and the "afterlife" is already introduced here (technically it began in series 7B). I think Clara and the Doctor definitely improves their dynamic in this series, sometimes Clara is a bit unlikeable aswell, but overall it's a great improvement from series 7B. The more simpler concept of the episodes work really well for me, episodes like Mummy on the Orient Express or Flatline aren't too big, but they're really enjoyable and are an absolute highlight.
Some downsides of this Series are that it's episodes are sometimes slower than usual, but I think it works in most cases here. Clara and the Doctor are fantastic here, but some scenes between them were a bit too much for me (Kill the Moon especially). Danny Pink is also a bit underdeveloped, he starts off well I think, but towards the end gets a bit annoying with his supposed grudge against the Doctor. He does make us question about the Doctor's ethics, but it gets a bit too much around the end. Missy and the Cybermen I think were great as the finale, albeit the reveal was a bit disappointing. Missy is a big character in 12's run, and I think she starts off really well here.
That's it for now, this series was really great. I actually finished this in about 5 days, the fastest I've ever finished a DW series, and I think it shows how enjoyable this was. Anyway, I'm hoping Series 9 is great aswell. I've heard good things about it.